Seed Heat-Treatment:
A Management Strategy for Controlling Bacterial Diseases

Bacterial Canker on Tomato

Bacterial Canker on Tomato

Seed heat-treatment is one cultural practice that prevents infected seed from resulting in losses to bacterial disease in the field. Bacterial canker, caused by Clavibacter michiganensis subsp. michiganensis (canker), bacterial speck (Pseudomonas syringae pv. tomato), and bacterial spot (Xanthomonas campestris pv. vesicatoria) are serious pathogens of tomatoes wherever they are grown. These diseases have been increasing in occurrence and severity in the northeastern United States. For many New Jersey tomato growers, bacterial canker is presently the most serious disease in the production system. A severe canker infection can result in complete loss of production, although losses when speck or spot are present in a tomato planting generally vary from none (minimal foliar injury) to significant yield loss, and are dependent on the source of the infection, weather conditions and cultural practices. To be effective, a management plan for bacterial diseases must integrate cultural and sanitary practices with chemical use.

Pathogen Survival and Spread

Infected seed is commonly identified as the source of bacterial infections, and while the speck and spot pathogens can be present on the seed coat, plants that are infected with bacterial canker will produce seed that may contain the bacteria both on and within the seed coat. Bacterial pathogens have been detected on living and dead plant material in infected fields, and canker cells are reported to survive on tomato debris (including seed) for up to 5 years if the debris is undecomposed. Survival is influenced by the depth to which the inoculum is buried, and the degree to which infested debris breaks down. Cells of all three pathogens will survive for relatively short periods of time in soil without solid debris.

Bacterial pathogens can survive for up to a year on infested tomato stakes, and presumably on greenhouse benches and plant debris within the greenhouse. Perennial solanaceous weeds like horsenettle may serve as overwintering hosts, and canker has been isolated from roots of this weed growing in fields without tomatoes for up to 2 years. Debris from annual solanaceous weeds like our nightshades may harbor canker through the winter as well. Additionally, solanaceous weeds serve as asymptomatic hosts on which the pathogen can multiply during the course of a growing season.

A common and serious means of dissemination is through transplant production. In this case, even low numbers of infected seed can result in widespread infections, as seedlings are in close proximity to one another and are handled frequently. Seedlings are also at risk for infection if tools, benches, etc. have not been cleaned properly, or there are potentially infected weed hosts or debris present in the greenhouse. Infected seedlings then are put into the field, where the infection becomes severe. In-field infections can originate from infected tomato plants, infected weeds, or infested debris and stakes. Once individual or groups of plants are infected, dissemination through the field is aided by cultural practices that injure the plants including tying, pruning, and harvesting as well as wind driven rain. Even injury as slight as breaking of the hairs (trichomes) on leaves and stems has been implicated disease spread. Infections are difficult to contain once they appear in a planting. The extent of the damage is largely related to the timing and method of initial of infection.

Management Strategies – Start with pathogen free seed

Heat treatment of seeds is a non-chemical alternative to conventional chlorine treatments for the elimination of seed-borne pathogens. Heat treatment has the additional benefit of killing pathogens such as the bacterial canker organism of tomatoes that may be found within the seed coat. Heat treatment is particularly useful for tomatoes and other crops that are prone to seed-borne bacterial infections, including peppers and cole crops. Seed heat-treatment follows a strict time and temperature protocol, and is best done with thermostatically controlled water baths. Two baths are required; one for pre-heating, and a second for the effective (pathogen killing) temperature.

Tea Infusers

Tea Infusers

Seeds are placed in porous containers (tea infusers, sections of window screen fastened at the edges with staples, etc.) and labeled by variety. It is important that the containers not be overfilled. Seeds must move freely so that hot water is in good contact throughout. The initial pre-heat cycle is for 10 minutes at 100ºF (37ºC) followed by the effective temperature cycle.

The following, from Dr. Sally Miller of Ohio St. Univ. are effective temperature protocols for several important crop groups:

Seed Type Water Temperature Minutes
Brussels sprouts, Eggplant, Spinach, Cabbage, Tomato 122F° 50C° 25
Broccoli, Cauliflower, Carrot, Collard, Kale, Kohlrabi, Rutabaga, Turnip 122 50 20
Mustard, Cress, Radish 122 50 15
Pepper 125 51 30
Lettuce, Celery, Celeriac 118 47 30

 
Immediately after removal from the second bath, seeds should be rinsed with cool water to stop the heating process. Afterward, seeds should be dried on screen or paper, and may be re-dusted with fungicide if desired. Pelleted seed is not recommended for heat treatment. Heat treat only seed that will be used during the current season.

Seed Heat Treatment Equipment And Supplies:

Water Baths
Laboratory supply houses sell many types of water baths. Depending on the size of seed lots you will treat, you may need larger units than those used by the RCE Vegetable IPM Program. We recommend a less expensive, analog unit for the pre-heat cycle, where temperature control is not as important, and digitally controlled unit for the effective temperature.

Water Baths

Water Baths

Examples:
Carolina Water Bath, 110 V- analog unit from Carolina Biological Supply
Precision Water Bath 2.5L; Digital Control; 115V 50/60Hz, 2.5A from Fisher Scientific
Teflon-Coated Mercury Partial Immersion Thermometers (2) (-20 to 110 C) from Carolina Biological Supply to monitor temperature in both baths.


Miscellaneous Supplies:

  • Distilled water is recommended to prevent mineral deposits on the baths.
  • Fiberglass window screen from which to make pouches for seed, or tea infusers.
  • Twine or wire to suspend the pouches or infusers in the baths.
  • Stiff wire or similar thin, rigid rod from which to hang the pouches/infusers.
  • Labels for each seed lot.
  • New envelopes for storing treated seed.

Rutgers Cooperative Extension offers Hot Water Seed Treatment Workshops. Contact your local Cooperative Extension office for details.
Article courtesy Andy Wyenandt and Kristian Holmstrom

Farm Calls: Advising Beginning Farmers Who Set Their Sights on Jersey Soil
Successful Urban Fringe Farmers
Know More than Just How to Grow Crops